3 LBS crappie....

[KDAVID1]

Arkabutla, Sardis, Grenada, I have caught 3lb + fish in all these lakes.

yep--caught one on Sardis lower weekend before last

[crappielimits]

Lake Shelbyville Il. North end Okaw Creek

Is this true? I would not have bet on bass getting much over 3 pounds in Ill.

There has been many 3 pound plus caught out of Weiss and it is as good as any outside of Mississippi!

[ArkSlabBusta007]

In Arkansas I would have to say either peckerwood or Conway, ever since I went to Mississippi I love fishing Arkabutkla, always catch a fish 2 pounds n over

[glasseyes]

Is this true? I would not have bet on bass getting much over 3 pounds in Ill.

There has been many 3 pound plus caught out of Weiss and it is as good as any outside of Mississippi!

Of couse , not sure why you would doubt this, I live in central Ohio and have caught 6 lb. bass from public lakes here, and I know there are bass caught much bigger then that by the bass fisherman.

[Phantom309]

"Health nuts are going to feel stupid someday, lying in hospitals dying of nothing"

Now why do I like that sayin ...

[crappielimits]

Of couse , not sure why you would doubt this, I live in central Ohio and have caught 6 lb. bass from public lakes here, and I know there are bass caught much bigger then that by the bass fisherman.

Sorry, but look at weigh in results for Ill. Crappie tournies are won with a 1 pound average and bass with a 3 pound average. I was just asking, never had heard of 3 pounders in Ill. or Ohio for that matter. The shorter growing season and extreme winters. I come from an area where we catch 6+pounders on most bass fishing ventures and most adult bass fishermen don't really bat an eye unless a fish is over 10. I just was asking, sorry I offended anyone.

[jeepguyjames]

Sorry, but look at weigh in results for Ill. Crappie tournies are won with a 1 pound average and bass with a 3 pound average. I was just asking, never had heard of 3 pounders in Ill. or Ohio for that matter. The shorter growing season and extreme winters. I come from an area where we catch 6+pounders on most bass fishing ventures and most adult bass fishermen don't really bat an eye unless a fish is over 10. I just was asking, sorry I offended anyone.

dont know about the orig lake mentioned in Ill....but ive fished ALOT here in Ohio, and a fair amount of tourneys and your pretty spot on.....in all honesty a 2lb or above crappie is a monster in my neck of the woods

[Wade2131]

That's AWSOME!!!!!!!!!!!

[fished-out]

Sorry, but look at weigh in results for Ill. Crappie tournies are won with a 1 pound average and bass with a 3 pound average. I was just asking, never had heard of 3 pounders in Ill. or Ohio for that matter. The shorter growing season and extreme winters. I come from an area where we catch 6+pounders on most bass fishing ventures and most adult bass fishermen don't really bat an eye unless a fish is over 10. I just was asking, sorry I offended anyone.

Saw one weighed at an tournament at East Fork in Ohio at 2.98; saw a picture of a shocked crappie out of Salt Fork that weighed over 4. State record in Ohio for both white and black is over 3 (I think they're over 4). They're rare, but they're in the midwest, including ILL.

[Wade2131]

they are mostly in "private lakes or farm ponds"..... below is Indiana DNR record for crappie

Crappie

4 lb. 11 oz.

Private lake, Jennings County

Willis Halcomb

1994