Bill seems different every day. Some day's color don't matter at all and others I wasn't getting bites and switched from silver to pink or chat and started catchin fish. Guess that's why crappie fishin is so much fun. Yesterday silver was the best. Messed around with those short fish all day instead of looking for bigger ones. When you find big schools like that it's fun to try new things. Tried 10 different colors of bg baby shad and they would only bite 2 colors. There were so many of them I could feel them bumping into the line.