Danbo: That's some great information....but It does spell out the pro's and con's doesn't it! People ask me all the time about that when I'm guiding and my usual answer is ...I DON'T KNOW! Too many fish to bait ratio...= small fish...... My customers keep alot of crappie...I encourage them to throw back smaller fish...but it's their call...I don't want to hurt myself either!... I've caught my fair share of 2lb+ crappie at oconee, But I doubt I'll ever see a 3lber! We have some of the best crappie anywhere due to Oconee's structure and massive amount of shad....But is it enough shad to go with a 10" limit? Lord knows the stripers and Hybes are rough on em!... Then there's the enforcement issue...If the state can't man the waters enough...You'll have the violators out there with no worries! I don't even go to Sinclair to fish...lack of cover and bait there has made for smaller crappie on the average than Oconee. Ask this million dollar question to 100 fishermen or heck...even Biologists for that matter....you'll get more opinions than we can digest!