Has it always felt the same power wise? Or does it feel lacking like something is off mechanically. Generally toons are propped large for top end, because hole shot doesn't matter and steering is more important. Make sure you have the correct motor and gearbox selected on the Mercury prop tool, it being a CT youll use less pitch since its a bigger prop but i would have thought 13P area would be perfet, you must have it loaded.
You won't notice any difference with SS vs alum in the same prop design with a toon.
The 50s and 60s really do like to be ran high, 5500-6000rpm so you do need to drop some pitch. I would drop 2 pitch and you should be better off, 11p 4 blade.
The other thing is your block and oil temp is cold, things move a lot better when they are warm vs 32f, youll gain at least 100rpm on a nice summer day. Probably more like 200.