I have been having issues myself that hopefully have been worked out but will share something I found. If you go to another shop they will have a different opinion alot of the time. If he wants to sell you a prop he should be willing to let you try it out or at least be willing to exchange for another one if that one dont suit, pretty common-place with prop shops because they know that EVERY boat is different and you may be loading it diffeent too.
Good luck
1990 Stratos 285 Pro 200 HP Merc
SpyderLok Rod Holders
Proud Member of Team Watch The Finger!!!
(662) 458-8925