I've fished Poinsette a number of times with little success. But then, I'm a newbie to this kind a fishin. Caught more mudfish/bowfin than anything else...if they even count. Trolled, drifted, & cast crank-baits, jigs with plastics, jigs with minnows, etc. In the weed beds, out in the middle, all over. Haven't tried Winder or the river in between....yet...but its close to home so I'll be back.