AGM and Glass Mat batteries take a slightly higher charge rate than standard lead acid batteries. To save your back I would buy a onboard automatic charger. Most have a set up where you remove a plug or slug or add one to set the proper charge rate for the type of battery you are charging. Your standard charger may charge at a high enough rate to recharge. Charge that new battery to full capacity before using. BBG Marine has a really good sale going on Minkota chargers right now. Think a single battery setup is like 69.00 and change. Need to call to get right pricing and Brian is a fine fellow to do business with.
Proud Member of Team Geezer
Charlie Weaver USN/ENC 1965-1979