I dont think the carp would damage it in any way. We have a pond about 3/4 acre and has one carp given she is about 20 lbs and it keeps the pond spotless as far as alge and grass goes, my neighbor about a mile down the road has a 2 acre pond and refuses to put any carp in and during the summer you cant fish it due to the alge and grass.... Im no expert but I would say go for it.