I have fished from most every type boat mentioned above and would not recommend a 10ft boat jon.... I have never seen any adult be able to sit on the front of a 10ft jon without the back being out of the water. Its funny to watch someone go to spinning circles when a stiff breeze comes up. 12ft boats are much more stable and tend to stay in the water much better when sitting on the front seat. The plastic boats are stable but do tend to dry rot over time and a little heavier than a riveted jon. Most 12ft jons are around 80 pounds and plastics are around 100 pounds. For me it would be the aluminum!!!!
A CORK TAKES ALL THE FUN OUT OF THAT THUMP!!!!