It depends on who you ask.
My father in law used to fish Stonewall in its early days for crappie and used to kill them in 3 or 4 spots. He claims there are very few Crappie left in the lake since they have not caught many in the last few years. Of course he only fishes from a stationary boat while casting under a bobber.
According to the DNR there are several good crappie lakes in the State in fishery reports.
However the WV forum has been non-existent in activity since Feb- March of 2015, for whatever reason.
I was quite surprised to see the icon lit up that there had been a post.