Don't know a lot about Pine, other than that it is full of REALLY small crappie. If I was going to crappie fish one of those 2 lakes, I would opt for Sycamore. Not a whole lot of big fish, but definately bigger than Pine. There are some good crappie in Sycamore. One of our club members caught the one in the pic below back in November, over 2 lbs.
I've caught quite a few nice bass while crappie fishing Sycamore, as well. If you decide to try Sycamore, give me a call and I'll share a few productive spots.
George
731-267-2322