Welcome aboard!
Just because no one else is posting trips to a fishing hole, that doesn't make it an "off topic" thread. Maybe Bill can move this into the main VA forum where it belongs.
We rarely hear about NCR and this 2009 Biologist Report explains why. My experience confirms the report. I spent 4 hours there the afternoon of 2/13/09 and was skunked. For what it's worth, here's the GPS track for that trip. The map software did not include the lake, so what you see is the contours before the lake was flooded. The launch facility is OK and there's unlimited parking. Later in the season, there's bound to be some action--even if the fish are small.
Also worth mentioning is the poorly marked entrance to the lake. Unless something's been done since '09, you can easily ride by & not see the dirt (gravel?) lane.
Let us know how you do.