Check out this website... and specifically look at "The Mill House" and "Deerfield Creek Cottage." They're not on the lake, but on a feeder creek not far from the lake.
They're owned by a friend of mine and some of my clients have stayed there. (We do offer a Fishing/Cabin Package Deal). But you can just rent the cabin without the fishing part.
"The Mill House" in particular gets rave reviews because it sits directly on the creek. The other one is very nice as well, it's just not right on the creek.
http://webreservationdesk.com/cwebs/...i=200173635027
If you go there, tell them I sent ya, please.