The Xi5 is the 1st trolling motor I've owned so I can't really compare it to anything. I've heard the Minn Kota in Youtube videos and it sounds loud. My friend has had several cable steer motors and I wasn't found of them do to their size. I have a 12' boat and space is limited. I was unsure if I really needed the GPS so my thoughts were to use it without it and if I do need it then spend the $449 for it at a later date. I've also read that the Xi5 makes corrections better when in lock mode than the Minn Kota. The Minn Kota starts up full blast whereas the Xi5 eases into it. Glad I could help Reaper.