Here's what I could find
I found a couple of small lakes in my book, but I've never gone fishing over there. It's the prettiest part of the state, though, and has some great hiking in the Hocking Hills
.
You've got Lake Snowden just SW of Athens, which is listed as 131 acres w/ 6hp limit. It has a notch limit on bass, is stocked with channel cats and has some saugeyes left from a stocking a few years ago. No mention of crappie.
To the NW, up in Hocking Hills, you have Burr Oak Lake, which is 664 acres w/ 10 hp limit. It's got it all in the way of fish: large and smallmouth bass, channel cats, saugeye, crappie and gills.They suggest fishing near the dam.
Wish I could offer first hand advice, but that's a hard drive from where we are and don't get over in that area like we used to. - Roberta
"Anglers are born honest,
but they get over it." - Ed Zern