I started like most people and bought all kinds of rods to save money. Like most people I upgraded over the years and finally ended up with Southern Crappie Rods. I wish I would have just bought them from the start they would have been much cheaper than all the other sets. I use 14' although the 16' are good. My deal is storage and the length of my boat so 14' is best for me. As far as guarantees, I guarantee Ed will take them back if you don't like them. He has a waiting list sometimes for his rods so no problem getting your money back if need be. I have broke 2 of his rods. Stepped on one while fishing and stuck one into my garage door. He has replacement section so you don't have buy whole rod. My wife is my main partner and she will tell you bout these rods. She got her first 2 pounder and many near 2 pounds after I got Southern rods. She says she can now see the bite and fishing is fun to her now so I get to fish more. Just my opinion.