There are three small lakes here in Northern Cayuga County, and all three are very similar in size, depths, structure and available cover. All three have large populations of black crappie, largemouth bass and pike.
They are (Ease to West):
Otter Lake
Parker's Pond
Duck Lake
There is a $5.00 launch fee at all three lakes, shore fishing isn't really an option unless you know someone with a cottage on the lake.
Otter Lake also has walleye, stocked yearly by the DEC, and Duck Lake has tiger muskie stocked annually by the DEC.
Duck Lake, by the way is where the state record black crappie was caught in 1998: 3 lb 12 oz.
I fish Parker's pond the most, simply because it is closest to the house. In the spring, I coach Little League and am starting to do the normal spring stuff around the house and yard (long, long honey-do list), so I try to maximize what little time I have for fishing by minimizing my travel time. I can load and unload the boat and all my gear and be on the water within 20 minutes from the moment that I decide I've got a couple hours to fish.
Otter Lake is an additional 5 minutes further away, and Duck 10 is an additional minutes further away. I fish them all, but fish the pond the most in the spring.