Some times you have to find what the fish want, and some times you have to do what you are comfortable with. Your comfort level with the technique you use can often be the difference between catching a lot or a little, big ones or small ones. On the really good days everything works. Gotta love those days! I've had days where you had to hold it completely still for 2-5 minutes before you'd get a hit and they would hammer it. I don't like those days, but like catching them when they really thump it.
The more you fish, the more you figure out what your natural progression will be for moving from technique to technique.