I have been using the Bang garlic spray with good success. Had some cans left from my bass tournament days so I tried it. Worked great and easier to use than the crappie nibbles I had been using. They also have a Shad scent but have not done as well with it. One of the top Pro's told me after a seminar that he did not care what brand or what flavor but to use something. I smoke so it is extra critical to use something.