My favorite grub is a white with chartreuse tail Southern Pro Triple tail, anything in this color combination works great where I fish. The other day I put my last 3X tail on and my fishin' buddy pilled out a package of white with chartreuse tail Sliders. I put one on and it worked just as well. Fished it th same way, slow, they hit it the same way as they hit the 3X tails. The Sliders are quite a bit softer and don't seem to hold up as well as the Southern Pro and other soft bodies. I don't do a lot of trolling, love to cast jigs, so, I do a lot of line watching. Works for me, catching quite a few down here!
Don't outsmart your common sense!
Jack