Saturday my buddy had the same identical set up that i have. !5 lb. braid to 10lb leader, same 1/16 ounce jig head & same hot pink/chartreuse tail bait out of the same shot of plastic that i made myself. The only difference was that i had a chartreuse crappie nibble & he didn't. I was catching fish & he wasn't. He said i can't get a bite & i told him it was the nibble & of course he didn't believe it. I told him aggravating him that i'd catch it for him lol Well i dropped down rught beside him & the crappie left his jig & came & bit mine & i put it in the boat. He had a few choice words for me but i may have been agging it on just a little bit. He then put one on & started catching a few. So far the nibbles seem to have been helping us get bit enough that i'm starting to get confidence in them.