I use the Bobby Garland shad baits all the time. But when I say they wouldn't take anything else, that's what I mean. I already tossed Bobby Garlands at them (including pared down versions), Road Runners, twisty tails, maribous, skirts, etc. This one particular jig body is the one they really wanted this go around. I think because they are already full of shad, they want only a little snack, not the whole fish, or even close to the whole fish.