Originally Posted by
mrdux
I've dealt with this situation in both guiding waterfowl hunts and fishing trips. I've had snow goose clients go back to lands we hunted on and try to get permission to hunt the same spots we hunted a few days or weeks ago. Rarely were they given permission because I spent decades making friends with farmers and landowners who trusted me because of the respect I showed to them and took care of their lands like it was my own.
I've been guiding fishermen for a couple of years and still have tons to learn but I do know people and how they can be. If a client gets in contact with me, I try to find out what they are looking for and why. I've had some who were very vague, almost secretive and others who came right out and told me they wanted to mark spots so they could fish them later. Being honest upfront with me is always better. I've had prospective clients who told me upfront they were going to GPS spots because they were on vacation, had their boat with them and wanted to save their time for fishing and not looking for fish. I still took them out to spots they should be able to catch fish. It was then up to them to duplicate my techniques and many were not able to, some do.
Two things I have to say about guides and their clients: If I take a person or group out for a trip, I'm going to go to the spots where I think the clients can catch the most fish or learn my techniques. Holding back most of ones spots just because one is afraid the client will go back to them is just wrong in my book. The thing that really chaps my arse is a guide being hired by a group and HE spends his whole day catching fish while the clients sat in the back of the boat watching. I'm not talking casting jigs to a bank--I'm talking the guide dropping a marker on a piece of structure, easing the boat up to the marker and essentially keeping the clients from even being able to get a bait near the structure while they sat in the back of the boat. I see it a lot sadly. When a group books with me, they are paying me to TAKE THEM FISHING. I'm not there to fish, I'm there to put the clients on fish while I control the boat, manage tackle or bait, and show them how to catch the fish. In that vein, If I'm not fishing, they have no right to ask if they can catch my limit also. That's not how I work.