I'm with the consensus - definitely a Warmouth Bass. We call them Goggle Eye in this area. I've seen many fly over my head after they hit a plastic worm and I think I'm crossing the eyes of a green carp. My boy has a knack for catching warmouth and gets at least one almost every time we go brim fishing. If you ever keep missing strikes in the same spot when fishing for bass, there's a real good chance that there's a warmouth at home in that spot.