For me my 10 biggest crappie i have caught was on jigs. All of those was caught using hot rods or shad body. As far as what catches most i think it depends on the lake and time of day. I do think jigs work better between 10 and 4pm for me anyway. Green river i havent used minners for several years and normally catch between 40 and 80 keeper size fish a trip. Cumberland average between 30 to 50 keeper a trip depending on what part of the lake and it is pretty even most jigs versus minner but i would give the edge to minners. Dale hollow only fished 6 times this year averaged 30 a day and would give the edge to the jigs there...