Well after much more research, obsession she calls it, I have determined that the perfect griddle for me is going to be difficult to find.
Most all are cold rolled steel tops over top of stainless steel burners, rigged into some sort of roll around metal cart, with and without covers. These as you know require upkeep and careful attention to seasoning. I really do not want that as I know me far far too well.
Ceramic tops, like the one in my driveway currently, are much easier to maintain, but at a price. Cannot use steel utensils as it will gouge. The surface is likely to peel away over time. I think these are now out as well.
Cast iron would be great, but the ones I saw are just toppers for grills and such already owned. These too require care and metal utensils are probably going to scratch the seasoning and make things cling here and there. These provide the best distribution of heat, and therefor the best results.
I really like the Cuisinart round griddles. Beautiful in design and look like quality workmanship. My issue is that I feel I would be chasing the food around way too much as there is no edge to catch it. Things would simply slide off into a nasty drip ring. Watched videos of them in use and that was exactly what I saw. People carefully lifting and moving stuff instead of sliding, flinging about, and stuff falling off the round surface. They sure look good though.
Stainless steel tops lack the even distribution of heat that all of the above have. They will have hot spots directly above the burners and cold spots right next to the burner. Stainless actually resists even heating. However, stainless does offer the ability to use metal utensils. It can also allow for a serious cleaning without worry of damaging the surface. I mean you could ruin it, but soap and water are OK. A pumice block lightly applied is allowed. Scraper tools with metal edges are allowed. No rust to worry about. Pretty much as easy to maintain as any of the others, if not a little easier.
Most stainless steel griddles are ones you lay atop a cook surface you already own. Some have cast iron stuck to the bottom to provide even heating, but those are commercial designs costing thousands of dollars. BlackStone offers a “stainless steel” model, but that really only means the cart is stainless. Same cold rolled top even if they choose not to make that evident.
So I found one that seems to fit my needs but is more than I really want to spend- $600 plus shipping. Cajun Fryer Griddle.
This thing is built like a tank. Heavy carbon steel frame that is not going to break. Stainless steel burner that turns out 90,000 btu. The size of the cooking surface is only 15” x 20” though, which is kind of small, but doesn’t take up a lot of room on the porch. Nice drip tray in the front where I can access it and monitor to see when it needs dumped. Big drippings hole, again up front not in the back where the food will want to hang out. Overall the unit weighs in at 100 pounds. Five year free replacement of parts if they break, and it looks to me like it would last a really long time and just sit there. Like one of those charcoal grills they set out in parks and such.
The single burner has a single knob to control flow and cranked all the way open would produce one very hot surface. Most other griddles run about half as much heat ( 50,000 btu ) and to heat twice as much surface. I imagine setting temperatures will be very tricky to manage. This unit is MADE IN AMERICA while none of the others can deny their Chinese heritage. Some city in China is the gas grill capital of the world and I am spitting mad that ain’t Milwaukee or Cleveland like it should be.
My wife likes to ask ridiculous questions, and she loves to do it anytime she sees that I am interested in something. So she asks- Honey, what do you plan on cooking with this thing ?
So I says I do all the cooking around this dump and so the answer is apparently whatever it is you will ingest for the next number of years. That and I see this as a healthy alternative for us.
Fish can be griddled and not deep fried. Our red meats can be seared and delicious without having to buy a new Chinese grill every couple of years. Chicken can be purchased in the large sized packages and cooked all at once and then placed in Tuperware and used for sandwiches and salads. We can make healthy Chinese dishes, and Mexican food, and the ever so healthy and delicious burger. In fact whatever I would normally cook in a skillet can be cooked on the griddle far more effectively. Vegetables on the griddle. I mean I suspect this thing is gonna be my go to kitchen gadget.
It is just that the surface is so small at 20 x 15. I mean it is bigger than any skillet I have, but still a little larger would be nice. They make the $900 plus shipping unit and it is 30 x 21 and weighs in at 150 pounds and has a thicker top- 3/8” stainless. Two burners producing the same 90,000 btu. Same everything else, but all at a price $300 more. Definitely be nice and outlast me. She will be the one cooking on it eventually and that thing would be a bear to roll about on the porch. If it fell over it would crush her. Hmmmmmm……
Anyways, as you can see I am engaged in a battle with the options here. This would have all been so unnecessary had FedEx done what they should have done to begin with.
Should I get the full size model ?