Thread: What kind of boat should I buy?? Lowe, Crestliner, Lund or Alumacraft

We've just about narrowed it down to an Alumacraft Competitor 165 model. I am going to Louisville in the am to check out a Crestliner FishHawk. I really like the Alumacraft though and think it will fit my fishing needs. I'd really like to look at a Starcraft but no dealer makes it tough to do that.

I've had my Alumicraft Navigator 175 for 7 years now with no real issues. The only complaint is with the livewell pump, it get's a little wonky once in a while and loses it's prime. I intend to solve that problem with a new pump as soon as I get a break from work and other commitments. My 2 cents are go as big as you can with your storage issues in mind, and the type of water you intend to fish. Also go with a 4 stroke motor. I've been impressed with my Suzuki. Twice a year I fish a 17,000 acre lake for a week & i have not had to refuel during the week with a 39 gallon tank. Have fun shopping and take your time.

Originally Posted by foolfishin

I've had my Alumicraft Navigator 175 for 7 years now with no real issues. The only complaint is with the livewell pump, it get's a little wonky once in a while and loses it's prime. I intend to solve that problem with a new pump as soon as I get a break from work and other commitments. My 2 cents are go as big as you can with your storage issues in mind, and the type of water you intend to fish. Also go with a 4 stroke motor. I've been impressed with my Suzuki. Twice a year I fish a 17,000 acre lake for a week & i have not had to refuel during the week with a 39 gallon tank. Have fun shopping and take your time.

Suzuki makes a fantastic motor. If I were to rig a boat with a 4 stroke there's no doubt I would have a Suzuki, tho I've never had an issue out of my Yamaha 4 stroke either.


On a side not foolfishin I live in West Lafayette. Small world...

Originally Posted by TrevorW

I have a Lund Explorer. It's nice and wide, dry as a bone not to mention Lund has the best resale value of any aluminum boat.

I have loved every Lund I have ever been in. From bare rental boats to fully decked out fishing boats. very nice and well made boats. Never heard anyone I would listen to have any complaints.

I prefer Lund, Starcraft, and Crestliner....in that order. I understand, and appreciate, the concern for a riveted boat. Makes perfect sense to me the concern about metal expanding and contracting, and with all those tiny holes in your boat... even though Lund guarantees the hull. Thing is, I've been on Lake Erie recently, in 2 boats, a Lund Rebel, then also in Crestliner FishHawk, and the Lund was drier and had a much smoother ride. Sold me.

a 4 year old post comes back to life, I'd suggest whatever you like as long as it doesn't LEAK !

Originally Posted by wannabe fisherman

a 4 year old post comes back to life, I'd suggest whatever you like as long as it doesn't LEAK !

or...it’s what ever floats your boat!!!

This is funny, I started this going on four years ago. Update, I bought the 165 Alumacraft Competitor and it's still going strong!