Definately an inertesting thread. I had never even heard of an automatic fly reel until now but then again I would have never looked for one.
I can only imagine what a "purist" fly fisher I know would say. He scolded me for using a reel that technicaly had a drag as much as it was. I think he would throw me in for using an automatic one. He would also say using anything but plain old cane poles is flat out cheating.
I don't see the issue with them, I doubt I will ever use one but hey, if I am still fly fishing at 85+ and need one then I am gonna buy one before I quit doing it.
I love taking my kids fishing, now if I could just manage to fish at the same time.