We rented a house on Star Island Drive on the lake about 2 years ago, middle of summer. We had minimal luck catching anything in that lake. My son managed 2 small bass and a bluegill or 2 in a 2 month period. The people I spoke to that I saw fishing told me they catch bass and bream in there, nothing heard about crappie. You're about 10 minutes away from the Anclote fishing pier and some good tackle shops (Armed Angler is about the closest). They catch trout, snapper, pompano, etc. Even if you're not fishing it is worth a trip to see the flats and talk with the locals fishing the pier. Enjoy it and good luck with the fish.
NUCANOE Pursuit
Kaku Voodoo
Wilderness Ride 135
Old Town Canoe