• The Live Bait Industry – What are they doing for the sport of Crappie Fishing? By Bernard Williams



    Crappie fishermen in general need to take a step back and look at what the live bait industry is doing for and to crappie fishing. The answer the first question; the live bait industry does nothing to promote or support crappie fishing. We (crappie fishermen) are one of the last vestiges of fishermen that still use live bait. Bass and walleye fishermen have long abandon live bait in tournament fishing.

    Artificial lures and soft plastics have become the staple in both sports. It’s why there’s so much money in bass and walleye fishing. The live bait companies don’t promote their products in the crappie fishing world simply because they think we can’t fish without it. They’re wrong, wrong, wrong.

    I’ve followed the professional crappie circuits for many years. What I see is 99% of all tournament fishermen use live bait. The live bait industry puts zero dollars into the sport versus soft plastics and lure companies supporting every aspect of the sport. These huge minnow farms could and should help promote the crappie fishing sport. When I look at the sponsor list for the professional crappie circuits, there’s not a single minnow farm or supplier listed. That shows you one thing; the live bait industry cares absolutely nothing about the sport of crappie fishing. These minnow farms should be the biggest supports of forums like crappie.com.
    It’s the dumbest thing I’ve ever heard, an industry that makes nearly 95% of its revenue from crappie fishermen and they’re not spending a single dime promoting the sport. In the business world we call that absolutely ludicrous.

    Crappie fishermen need to wake up and let their voices be heard. We have the keys in our hands. If the live bait companies don’t care about promoting the sport that feeds them, then we need to show them we can do without their product.

    In my opinion, it’s past time for live bait to be outlawed in tournament fishing. Tournament crappie fishing is a sport, there’s very little sport in putting a live minnow on a hook and enticing a crappie to bite it. It’s no different in shooting a deer eating out of a trough of corn. Dove hunting over a baited field is illegal; shooting a deer eating out of a trough is illegal to a certain extent. You must be a hundred yards or better away. We should use the same logic in competitive crappie fishing.

    Don’t get me wrong, this is a free country. Nobody can dictate what you can use when you fish. I’m just saying in competitive fishing, the fish should have a chance. Using live bait is not fishing, it’s harvesting. If you’re fishing for food or running a guide service fine, using live bait in competition fishing takes the sporting chance away. If we consider competition fishing a sport, then we should treat it like a sport.

    You couldn’t pay a bass fisherman to use live bait no matter what situation they’re fishing, even though some of the largest bass ever recorded was caught on shiners. The huge amount of money poured into the bass fishing comes from the lure and tackle industry. Until crappie fishermen wrap their minds around using artificial bait, the sport of crappie fishing will always play second fiddle to other fishing sports.

    I see it coming; the State of Maine banned live bait in lakes that contain brook trout. They did that back in the 1960s. This policy prevented the spread of non-native fish and caused the brook trout to thrive. The UK banned live bait because it introduced alien species into their habitats which brings diseases and parasites. We’ve got to act quickly before the animal rights activists jump into the fight.

    So what can we crappie fishermen do? We can call, write, email and lobby the live bait producers and ask them to do more to support the last group of fishermen that use their product. Professional crappie fishermen need to demand the pro circuits ban live bait. When we speak as one voice, I can promise you we will be heard. Bernard - Outdoor Writer
    Comments 24 Comments
    1. huntinslabs's Avatar
      huntinslabs -
      Very well said, and I agree on all accounts. I absolutely agree it is past time to remove live bait from the tournaments. And once that is done the industry will really take off. Stores would be forced to stock a larger amount of tackle for Crappie fishing, win win. I could not even come close to telling you when the last time I had minnows or shiners in my boat.
    1. tenncrappie's Avatar
      tenncrappie -
      Very well said but there's the other side of the story. we talked to our supplier and he said he'd never been approached. So we made a deal to advertise on our shirts for free minnows. Seems like a good deal to me.
    1. BAMA S's Avatar
      BAMA S -
      Good read, good thoughts. We use minnows but its such a hassle to keep them alive overnite. I have a two hundred gallon tank set up with an aerorater on it. Buying buy the pound is not expensive but we have a local store that charges 3 Bux a dozen. They normally die quicker than the ones outa my tank. Go figure. We are 50/50 minnows or jigs.
    1. scrat's Avatar
      scrat -
      Why imitate a minnow when you can use the real thing. I catch my own minnows and I fillet and eat the crappie that tournament fishermen would want me to release. This is a two sided coin and tournament fishing is all about $$$$ money not catching a mess of fresh crappie for the table. Talking about trying to ban something because you don't agree with them not giving $$$$ money is not sporting anyway and this article that is helping PETA to ban all fishing. And that's all I got to say about this...
    1. Billbob's Avatar
      Billbob -
      good read
    1. ET Fish's Avatar
      ET Fish -
      Live bait and artificials both have their place. I only use minnows in colder weather. My opinion is that a tourney can allow or disallow. A fair playing field is all I would ask for. If you choose to not support the live bait industry, that is a personal choice.
    1. hays47's Avatar
      hays47 -
      This kinda smacks of political blackmail to me. In that if you don't sponsor our tournaments let me see what I can do to harm your business.

      Don't we have enough of this stuff in the USA right now. I don't fish tournaments so should I write columns about how they should be controlled or even banned.

      I like to fish when I feel like it. Not when some tournament is scheduled. However I realize not everyone feels the way I do. If there were not millions of anglers who do enjoy them. I am sure they would disappear. So while I do not fish tournaments . I in no way would speak out against them. It is purely a matter of personal preference.

      There is enough opposition to two of our outdoor pursuits. Hunting and fishing have enough enemies.Really bothers me to see one of our own add fuel to the other sides fire.
    1. Mrs. Crappie Stalker's Avatar
      Mrs. Crappie Stalker -
      Bream/bluegill fishermen use crickets and meal worms; catfishermen use nightcrawlers. Live shrimp are used in the southern coastal waters. Crappie fisherman are NOT the "last vestiges" of fishermen that use live bait.

      I'm certainly not the best fisherman out there, but I'm not the worst either, and I've never seen that "using live bait isn't fishing, it's harvesting." If that were the case, why did Tommy Skarlis win CrappieMasters in Mississippi pulling cranks? You've made some pretty big claims in your article that I don't think you can back up.

      If live minnows are such a sure fire crappie catching method, why are there so many companies in business producing soft plastics, crappie nibbles, hundreds of styles and sizes of jigs, feather jigs, hair jigs, crappie cranks, roadrunners, rooster tails . . . . . I could go on and on. I'd venture to guess that the revenue stream from all of this greatly exceeds the revenue from selling minnows.

      I use minnows when the conditions call for it. Some days they want them and some days they don't. I don't always have them in the boat, but if I WANT them, I'm gonna GET them.
    1. kycreek's Avatar
      kycreek -
      "It’s no different in shooting a deer eating out of a trough of corn."

      I'm not a tournament fisherman & probably never will be, but I don't agree with that statement at all.
    1. Speckanator's Avatar
      Speckanator -
      Never use em anyway
    1. RetiredRR's Avatar
      RetiredRR -
      Options & opinions, everyone has one. I'm just glad we don't have someone come up with the idea of fishing with minners on odd days and fishing with plastics on even days. Juuuuusssssst Kiiiiiidddding.
    1. cropiegetter's Avatar
      cropiegetter -
      I was just thinking if minnow company's did sponsor tournaments then the cost would go up. I personally don't want to see crappie fishing become so commercialized as the sport of bass fishing has. This is my two pennies.
    1. Tony the Tiger's Avatar
      Tony the Tiger -
      I guess catching perch "crappie" will be like everything else pretty soon in that if it's not done the political correct way we will start having protesters at the launches and bait dealers will be picketed.
    1. Trapper's Avatar
      Trapper -
      This is about the dimmest article I have read lately. .......come on Government gives us more rules as a burden on our backs , beat us down until we don't have any more choices unless we pay for the commercial community to live the high life .
      Fishing should be fun as long as it doesn't deplete the critters we are after .
    1. TerryD's Avatar
      TerryD -
      x2 what Trapper said!
    1. SeaRay's Avatar
      SeaRay -
      I have to agree that there are some ill advised comments as well as invalid statements. One such as bass fishermen not using live bait, apparently the writer is unaware of the very lucrative "wild shiner" industry in Florida which is the exclusive domain of trophy largemouth bass fishermen.
      Besides, a young child is not always adept enough to detect the delicate bite on a jig, but they can sure see a bobber go down and set the hook on a nice crappie. A live minnow can make the difference is a good day or bad day for kids and adults alike.
    1. brucec's Avatar
      brucec -
      Wow, what a bashing of small business!!! This is total BS!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    1. BassCat21's Avatar
      BassCat21 -
      I apologize for not being as clear in my article as i intended. I tried to make two points.
      1. Tournament fishermen should not use live bait. It takes (in my opinion) the sport away.
      2. The Live Bait Industry should promote the sport of crappie fishing.

      I'm in no way trying to tell Crappie Fishermen what bait to use. If you're fishing for food or fun, use whatever you wish. Young kids should be introduced to crappie fishing in any manner their parents wish to use.

      If we're going to enjoy this fantastic sport we need all the help we can get to keep it going. I'm so glad to get you thinking of it as a sport. I enjoyed the comments and opinions.

      I'm not trying to bash anyone or any business big or small. I'm only suggesting that they put something back into the sport. They should be crappie.com's NUMBER 1 SUPPORTER.
    1. Minners N Jigs's Avatar
      Minners N Jigs -
      I would imagine that they (the minner suppliers) would bring more to the table "IF" they stood to gain from what it "financially" what artificial lure manufacturers do. Per your article "the minnow" already owns 99% of the market share. From a logistics and practical stand point it would be a near impossible sell for one farm to promote "my minners are better than their minners, so Mr. Angler you should buy MY minners". How does ACME Minner Farm in Mississippi benefit from a crappie tournament on Grand Lake in Oklahoma. You see artificial lure manufacturers shelling out the big money because of the financial gain potential that it offers them. It makes a lot sense for one, for the other, not so much.
    1. badaxed's Avatar
      badaxed -
      "It’s no different in shooting a deer eating out of a trough of corn."
      SNORT, SNORT, Lead me to the trough of minnows.
  • .

BACK TO TOP