Well I have seen and witnessed on more than one occasion, People keep them that would just produce fillets the size of a bluegill fillet. I have heard it said if it has eyeball and a tail its big enough to get a fillet off of it. I was just wondering what the majority was looking for in a keeper crappie. now I know, the majority says 10" and up is what most consider a eating size crappie. Very interesting, if you dont ask the questions you can never get any answers.