Originally Posted by
crappiemax
As you know, lots of variables come into play when choosing a head size. Wind is one example and speed/depth control is another. Especially with deeper fish a heavier head will allow a faster retrieve while maintaining a deeper presentation. With a lighter head a much, much slower speed would need to be used to maintain that same depth. I have seen where just a slight adjustment in (faster/slower, deeper/shallower) presentation could mean a significant increase/decrease in catch vs. hits ratio.
Last weekend we fished a school that was 9-12' deep in 14-16 FOW. Most of the time we had very little (if any) wind to contend with. We started with 1/16 oz heads. We got bit but it was pretty slow. Even though we were getting hits we weren't hooking many, maybe 1 out of 10 or 15. In a short time we switched to a slightly heavier 3/32oz head. Action immediately picked up and we were hooking about 60% of our hits. We switched plastics around too from stingers to swimbaits to tubes. Eventually orange/chart tubes won out.
More than anything I suspect the larger heads allowed us to give the faster action the fish wanted in the deeper water.
I will say we even tried some 1/8 oz heads to see if we could improve our success even more but it seemed to have more of a negative effect so we switched back to the 3/32.