Color is important but I wouldn't overthink your situation. Just find a few favorites for each water condition and stick with them. Build confidence in a few colors and you won't have to worry about a box full of wacky colors. In my part of the world, I bet that if I only fished with 5 colors for an entire year - a blue and white, pink and white, black and chartreuse, red and chartreuse and solid white, I would catch as many as if I threw every color in the box. It's just my opinion but if you find a few colors you have confidence in, stick with them and keep the baits in the water.