The BG and the Slabbuster are very similar and perform almost identically; so between them one has an expanded color selection. I prefer the Slabbuster by a hair where the colors overlap. I don't even carry minnows; so I never tip them and prefer the concave side up. Same for the smaller 1.5" Southern Pro stingers. Pearl is one of our best colors in both. In the bigger sizes natural shad colors work almost as well. I fish these very slow. You can't keep that tail still. The Pearl is a fantastic color for when the crappies come up and feed just below visibility when you can see the occasional flash. Then it can be dip and lift until you get tired of unhooking fish. You simply watch for the bait to disappear and set your hook.