Reply With QuoteMay want to post this in Louisiana and Texas forums also as Toledo Bend is a border water between the 2 states. I don't know the correct answer but was always told that whichever launched you used, you needed to abide by that states' regulations.
HaHa: 0
Crappie.com 3K Star General
Clark's Hill Limits
I figured I'd pose this question to everyone to see what the general consensus is. For years me and many of my fishing buddies have wondered about the creel limit on Clark's Hill for crappie. Georgia's limit is 30 per person and South Carolina's limit is 20 per person. You can fish the lake with either state's fishing license legally. It's not like Lake Wylie....I've always abided by the law in the state I hold my license (SC) regardless of whether I'm fishing GA or SC waters... I've heard some folks say that it depends on where you fish i.e. if you are fishing in SC keep 20, in GA keep 30 no matter your license. I've always said it's dependent on which state's game warden checks you as to which laws they are checking you by. If I were to catch 30 in GA and then transport them back into SC, I could be in trouble if I encountered a game warden on the way home. Plus, I don't feel like there's an argument to be had if you possess a SC license, but here's the rest of the story....
A friend a mine was fishing in SC waters yesterday and happened to be fishing next to a man and wife from GA. They had a GA license, a GA registration, and GA plates on their truck. A SC game warden checked them and they had 48 fish in the boat. They were under the impression they could keep 30 per person, but instead they were ticketed a hefty fine and their fish were taken. The game warden told them it was 20 per person in SC. I believe they have a legitimate argument to make, but they were on the SC side. What is everyone's thoughts?
P.S. several years ago I posed this very question to 3 SC game wardens at the Sportsman's Classic and none of them could give me a straight answer. I don't plan on ever keeping over 20 per person in my boat, but I would like to know what the rule actually is. Is it your license or the side of the river you are on?
Crappie.com Legend
May want to post this in Louisiana and Texas forums also as Toledo Bend is a border water between the 2 states. I don't know the correct answer but was always told that whichever launched you used, you needed to abide by that states' regulations.
Dwyane
The only place where success comes before work is in the dictionary!
SMILE- A curve that can set a lot of things straight!Crappie Buster thanked you for this post
Crappie.com 3K Star General
I fully believe the warden is correct. On a shared lake, the boat limit depends on your states law with a catch! Here’s what I believe to be true, if a SC fishermen puts his boat in on the Georgia side of the lake and fishes Georgia waters he can catch 30, as with a Georgia angler, he can catch 20 from SC waters and 10 more from Georgia waters if wants to. If he puts his boat in on the SC side, and gets checked at the ramp in SC with over 20 he is breaking the law as well.
Last edited by Inkdabber; 03-18-2021 at 03:01 PM.
Professional Crappie Removal
Safe and ethical
One rod, one jig, one fish at a time.
Slabmaster
Inkdabber you are correct in my opinion sir. Pretty obvious the rules and regs here but for one man to follow is the problem. If in doubt side with the states limit you have the license with. Tight lines guys.
Guppy
I just read the agreement between SC and Ga on Georgia's DNR page. It's fairly clear that you must meet the possession limit of the state you are in at all times. Personally I think the two states should agree upon common regs for each species to elevate confusion.
FisherFore LIKED above post
Super Moderator
* Crappie.com Supporter
A Ga resident fishing SC waters has to follow SC rules and regs....even size limits. A SC resident can follow Ga regs IF he trailers to Ga and stays on the Ga side of the lake. You wont get checked on the Ga side by SC wardens and visa-versa. I was told you and I could literally "bump boats" if we had a determined state line in the middle of the Savannah River and I could catch and keep 30 without a size limit and you could only catch and keep 20 with an 8" size limit. This came directly from "the horse's mouth" when Ga quit following all of SC rules on the adjoining lakes. I was also told that on these lakes the Ga DNR didnt see any reason to impose a size limit and also didnt see any reason to lower the creel limit on crappie. They felt the lakes didnt have any problems with the reproduction rates and seen no reason to make any changes. That's where they butted heads with the SC DNR and went their own way.
Health nuts are going to feel stupid someday, lying in hospitals dying of nothing.
Crappie.com 3K Star General
Thanks for the responses. Like I said, I just keep my 20 and I'm glad to have them. I've always been concerned about catching and keeping 30 in GA and then transporting them back into SC. I'd hate to have to make a case to a game warden at a traffic stop that I was fishing in GA....
Makes sense to follow the rules of the state for which you are fishing in. After all, that's what the game warden will be checking you by.
Hooking up every chance I get!
Super Moderator
* Crappie.com Supporter * Member Sponsor
OK so let me add this to the conversation, say you used a ramp in Ga and have 30 crappie limits. You get pulled over in SC by a SC warden and he finds you have over the limit for SC. You tell him you fished in Ga, you think you won't get fined. How does he know you really fished in Ga. Yes I do think you will get fined for over limit.
PROUD MEMBER OF TEAM GEEZER ---------
Ascend 133X 13' - MotorGuide Xi3 & Mercury 4
Crappie.com 1K Star General
We should invite a SC and GA warden to join Crappie.com just to help work out issues like this......?
Do you guys know any?
Sent from my iPhone using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app
Crappie.com 1K Star General
For the record, I always thought when fishing lakes with reciprocal agreements you had to abide by the laws that pertain to the state license you hold. No?
Sent from my iPhone using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app
