For those who have caught and/or eaten both: please vote. :)
Printable View
For those who have caught and/or eaten both: please vote. :)
You need another that just says both, lol.
Black crappie for me. It may be all in my head but they seem to fight a little harder. They usually seem to taste a little better also. Like I said though it may just be all in my noggin. [emoji39] I will take either on any day [emoji106]
Black crappie certainly fight a little harder but I can't tell the difference in taste between a black and a white. Here in Texas the white crappie are larger on average.
Both to catch and eat.
I like them on a plate, when their fried, I cannot tell the difference.
Black crappie pull a little harder but for eating l can’t tell any difference.
Both are good.
Sent from my iPhone using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app
I think black fight a lil harder. If I was to fry them both up & put them on a plate in front of you you couldn't tell the difference. Just my opinion!!
Sent from my SM-S908U using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app
I am happy with either one for eating and catching