Printable View
Ran across a post that said the WM Tightline and B&M Pro Staff Trollers seem to be the same rod... only differences were color and graphics. Can anyone comment on this? If they are not the same rod, I'd like to know the differences and your opinions. Thinking about getting 4 for spider rigging.
Thanks
Is this a great board or what? I got a p.m from Wally Marshall himself letting me know that the rods are made in different factories. Now, if there's anyone out there who's used both of them?... Might have to drive to Caruthersville to try both for myself (Grizzly Jig carries both).
Thanks again Mr. Crappie.
The Tightline Special is a far better rod. It is a beast! Plenty of tip action and amazing strength. If you will count the guides you will realize they are not the same rods. Best spiderrigging and longlining rods ever made. I have wasted alot of money on others!
B'n'M Trolling Rods are the best. I wouldn't trade these for anything! Try these, you won't be sorry.
The BnM Pro Staff Trolling Rod is one heck of a rod. I would recommend it to anyone. I have had it pretzled down under the boat many many a time where any other rod would have snapped like a toothpick but it held up. That elusive 3 pounder no problem with this rod. Plenty of tip action and a long butt to fit the rod holder. You can get replaceable tips from BnM if you so happen to break one. As for Wally Marshall tightline rod it looks quality as well. Needs a replaceable tip for them though. Heard alot of good things about them. If I was in the market for these I would wait for Bass Pro to run a sale on them, then buy what I wanted. The BnM Pro Staff Trolling Rod has proven itself to me. Well satisfied.
How long a rod are you looking at....If it's a 16 footer then I would go with the BnM...the 16 foot tightlines are too stiff for spider rigging...I love the action of the 18 footers but they are still a little high for my taste...I love my Wally's but when I started playing with pushing jigs I bought BnM's....I did have one break for what I considered no reason and I contacted them and they got me a new tip for it...very courteous and helpful....
One man's opinion...I have both and prefer the BnM poles....However, if you don't have time to go to the gym take the WMs fishing...:) You can get a work out & fish at the same time....As you said::BEAST:::Quote:
Originally Posted by crappielimits
I do think the WM rods are well made...Mine are IM8 with plenty of eyes..Never figured out why they don't have replacement tips....
I'm not saying they are the same blank but the number of eyes has nothing to do with the blank...You can put as many or as few as you want on a blank...
AUTiger... Thinking about 12' rods.
To all who responded... This is just the kind of info. I was looking for. Weight, stiffness, tip availability, durability and general "feel" (even though they will be in holders most of the time).
Hope I can make a "field trip" to Grizzly Jig's spring tackle show but It's a long drive from KC... We'll see.
Thanks again.
Same here. This reason alone has kept me from buying anymore WM. I like the rod but if I can't order a replacement tip I'm not buying anymore. I'm pretty hard on my rods and have bought many replacement tips from BnM. Heck, I have two WM rods in my garage that I would buy replacement tips for if I could.Quote:
Originally Posted by DonG
I was lucky enough to fish with both this fall, and decided on the BnM's for myself. Just put reels and line on 9 of them last night. I went with 14 fters.
Grizzly tackle has tips for WM and most other rods. If you do not have their catalog by all means get one,
Reckon that Wally Pole is making my arm tired? Heck, I thought it was from lifting them heavy fishes.Quote:
Originally Posted by DonG
I need a second opinion.:)
I have 6 B&M poles never had a problem with any of them. just got 2 new wally rods, haven't had a chance to use them yet.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cane Pole
I've held WM rods and BnM rods (10-12ft'rs) and the WM's do seem to be a little more "end heavy" (tip end, that is). Don't know if it's a bigger blank, more guides, or exactly what the reason is ... but, if it ain't balanced out correctly, it is going to wear on your wrists ... especially if you "hold" your pole in hand.
In your case, Tom ... I don't know if I'd go with the BnM' long poles, either. Them big slab fishes you catch might bust 'em up too often ;)
Maybe you just need to get you a single, good 7-8ft'r ... and ease up a little closer to your honey holes :p (something like a Sam Heaton rod). If you just "hafta have" a long pole ... take a look at the Duckworth FnF rods (Tenn handle version, not the 8ft'r with balance kit). You can find either/both of these on the BnM site (and click on this site's Sponsor banner for BnM, and support this site with your purchase). Either that, or change your KY Rig setup for a slip float setup, and leave your rod lying in the boat (rather than holding it all the time) :eek:
... luck2ya ... cp :cool:
I have and use both. I use B&M BGJP 14 for slow trolling with anything under 3/4 ounce. The WM are to stiff for me on the light stuff. I use the WM for crankbaits and other heavy duty trolling.
Here is some data for weight vs deflection I took using three different rods that I posted over on the VA board. The B-n-M Pro Staff rods and the Wally Marshall Titeline Special rods are definitely not the same. The B-n-M rods compare closer to the WM Signature Series.
http://www.crappie.com/gr8vb3/showth...191#post487191
I have a Grizzly Jig catalog and it was suggested I check it for tips to fit WM rods. They are on page 40 of the 2008 catalog. I have three spare but sections I could never bring myself to throw away when the tips broke in a place where it was not practicle to repair them. I might just have to order some tip sections and see how they work.