Thread: Favorite crappie lure or method

Perhaps I should start. Cold water such as ice fishing or first ice out requires very slow jigging. I like either a cast master with a mousy or very small mill worm when fishing through a hole in the ice. A close second would be a 1/16 ounce jig with the same bait to sweeten it. I usually jig it a few times then stop. When stopped I get most of my bites. I sometimes use a small bobber when jigging so when I stop jigging it will move just slightly, set the hook! Problem with the bobber is you need to reset the depth if you reel your line in.
Early season cold open water I usually use a bobber with a 1/8 or 1/16 ounce jig but no bait added. I adjust the depth until I find where many of the crappie are located at. After a while I may re- adjust the depth when the bite slows down. I really like a silver- Nickle plated head with some white calf tail. At times depending on water clarity i do change colors such as yellow or even some greens. I have fished the Chickahominy river in Va and found that a orange head and calf tail works best in high off colored water.
As water warms a few degrees I usually cast 2 jigs and sometimes using a 3/16 ounce for one for a little more weight and casting distance. The fish will start to be a little more aggressive so the medium slow retrieve works well for me. When water temperatures warm a few more degrees a faster retrieve can put more fish in your creel at a quicker pace. Also some larger lakes will have streams large enough to pull spring crappie to the warmer water when sunlight can penetrate and this can be a magnet for a spring run and spring prespawnd fish. I am sure some have other ideas and perhaps they work well for you so lets give each other some ideas.

My favorite ice fishing lure is a Hali jigging lure with a wax worm. I will run dead stick rods with 1/32 or a 1/16 jigs baited with wax worms or minnows also while I'm jigging the hali's.
In spring ,I like to drift in the boat running 1/8oz jigs with minnows ,wax worms and nibbles(thanks Chaunc). I also will use crappie/perch rigs using the same bait. I love fishing brush piles with jigs with plastics and nibbles. We caught quite a few crappies while we were trolling for walleye on worm harnesses and they were all dandys. If we get any ice this year,I'm going to use nibbles for bait to see if crappies bite on them in winter as well as they do in spring and summer.

Sent from my LML212VL using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app

Originally Posted by patrapper

My favorite ice fishing lure is a Hali jigging lure with a wax worm. I will run dead stick rods with 1/32 or a 1/16 jigs baited with wax worms or minnows also while I'm jigging the hali's.
In spring ,I like to drift in the boat running 1/8oz jigs with minnows ,wax worms and nibbles(thanks Chaunc). I also will use crappie/perch rigs using the same bait. I love fishing brush piles with jigs with plastics and nibbles. We caught quite a few crappies while we were trolling for walleye on worm harnesses and they were all dandys. If we get any ice this year,I'm going to use nibbles for bait to see if crappies bite on them in winter as well as they do in spring and summer.

Sent from my LML212VL using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app

The nibbles don’t dissolve in the colder water like the do in above freezing temperatures. I use an oil based attractive on the ice. Gonna try slab and g sauce this year. Been using gulp or Berkeley sauce over the years. My best baits are 4mm tungsten tipped with waxworms for crappies and gills and small spoons tipped with maggots for perch.

Back when Hector was a pup my best crappie jig (thru the ice) was a hot pink rocker. Tipped with a couple maggies it accounted for 90% of my crappie. Didn't matter if I was fishing Conneaut Lake or Horseshoe Pond in Erie. As soon as ice out 1/16 oz. white marabou jig or if using a fly rod #4 white marabou streamer were my best bets. I think the rocker jigs were made by Dot Lure Co. and looked like the attached pic but more of a hot pink color.

Originally Posted by mchech

Back when Hector was a pup my best crappie jig (thru the ice) was a hot pink rocker. Tipped with a couple maggies it accounted for 90% of my crappie. Didn't matter if I was fishing Conneaut Lake or Horseshoe Pond in Erie. As soon as ice out 1/16 oz. white marabou jig or if using a fly rod #4 white marabou streamer were my best bets. I think the rocker jigs were made by Dot Lure Co. and looked like the attached pic but more of a hot pink color.

I still have a few of those jigs somewhere. Do you fish horseshoe pong in the open water also?

Only thru the ice on Horseshoe & Misery Bay. Right off the corner of one of the houses was really a hot spot for crappie back then. I often wandered what it would be like in the spring for crappie. I have done some open water fishing for steelhead off the docks in the marina. Boat fishing for perch or walleye out in the main lake till medical problems ended that.

I never found the nibbles or any attractant to work as sell as mousies and very small mill worms ( tipping a jig with natural bait).
The other thing I have notice I seem to catch more bluegills on dark color jigs then white or yellow. Both for open water and on the ice. Perhaps it is just me?

My favorite is a 4 mm gold tungsten tipped with a waxworm, fished on three pound test ice line. Black, purple, and pink are others I’ll give a try too.