Gulp and Gulp Alive have been fairly productive from time to time. The 1inch minnows and the crappie fry work well for bluegills and/or crappie. Now whether they out produce live bait my expreience says rarely.These 2 baits do have the advantage of being small and slender which is sometimes what the fishes prefer.Like most baits time and circumstances dictate what the fish want. As a side note the 1 inch minnow on a 1/64oz or smaller jighead makes a great bait for flyrodding fished ubnder a strike indicator which doubles as a float. It works great for gills or speks.