C-Store is no longer, so the only place in Tightwad (that I know of) is Independent Outdoor Specs. It is just down the road, west on 7hwy, from where the C-store used to be. I typically grab my minnows from Everharts if I'm passing through Clinton or at Bucksaw if I fish from their ramp. I have gotten a few from Independent Outdoor Specs on a Sunday this past winter since Everharts isn't open on Sundays and Bucksaw wasn't open yet for the season. Others may respond shortly with other options.