Great catch! Have never used the Firetiger Bandit 300, but I know they work well for others a lot of the time. I usually prefer a lighter color crankbait.
When I am fishing alone, I will almost never shift to neutral but may turn the boat a bit in the direction to the side where the rod is. That slows the retrieve of getting the fish in. (and you can reel in a crappie so much faster than a bass, hybrid, catfish----always say that when reeling in a crappie is that it is 'waterskiing'--with treble hooks on a crankbait the crappies seldom get off...and when you reel fast enough the slab will be brought in like a frisbee)
When someone is fishing with me, I will usually shift to neutral-----would rather me lose a fish than having someone else lose one!
Husker
the trick to catch that finnicky speck....
gently set the hook just before the peck