If you ran it up to 6,000 or over and it hit the rev limiter I’d say your tach is pretty accurate. If it is a 13-19 would drag it back close to 5900-6000. 13/21 would put it right in the operating range. 19 would maintain your hole shot with little not able difference. 21 would slow your hole shot a little but give you more top speed and keep you in operating range for that motor. Ideal situation is have someone you could borrow a prop from. Some dealers actually have used props around the will loan you.
Proud Member of Team Geezer
Charlie Weaver USN/ENC 1965-1979