Thanks: 
Reply With QuoteThe way I see it every monster crappie was once a little miniscule thing so I like em all
Crappie.com 1K Star General
Catching is fun but it nice when you can get on the big fish too.
Slabmaster II
The way I see it every monster crappie was once a little miniscule thing so I like em all
Trophy King II
All of the above. I dont mind having to work through 30 or 40 less than crappie to pick 8 or 10 good eaters. This may sound like i am kidding but i dont mind losing a few bigguns along the way. They going back anyway and saves me the trouble
Sent from my SM-N970U using Crappie.com mobile app
Crappie.com 3K Star General
Well guess it's time to chime in. Frankly I have standards within 2 categories - Tacos & Hammers. I am always fishing for Hammers these days, I keep quality Tacos as a by-catch. I don't target Tacos anymore. The few on this site that have fished with me know I throw a bunch back. I like to judge a Taco before tossing into the cooler, I turn them so I can look at them along their back. If the fish is 11-12 inches but poor - skinny I toss them back. If it looks like there is no meat up near the Dorsal fins I toss them back to gain weight.
Super Moderator
* Crappie.com Supporter
I very rarely keep any. Only if we don’t have any in the freezer and we don’t eat crappie that much. Girls would rather have Gorton’s
Spoonminnow haha
Trophy King
I just love the catching. Big numbers and the limit aren’t important either. I do love the eating so a good mess is all I need to keep.
Crappie.com 2K Star General
* Crappie.com Supporter
Fishing and catching anything is what pleases me. Big is a bonus.
Sent from my iPhone using Crappie.com
Catch all you can when you can!
An old man in his old boat having fun!
FISHING REPORT: ‹Caught two docks, 3 trees and a stump- threw them back!Smitty39365 LIKED above post
Keeper
* Member Sponsor
8.5 inch to 9.5 inch IMO make the best fillets. Thin, crispy, and perfect texture.
Don't get me wrong, I'll eat the big ones also - but my favorites now are the smaller fish.
https://highqualityfishing.com/
Home of "The Foot Fisher"
Foot-Steering Attachment For Transducer Poles!
Crappie Wall Hanger II
* Crappie.com Supporter
Little ones til I catch a dozen, then on to the big girls! Like the saying goes, size matters!
Crappie.com 3K Star General
I'd rather catch one slab over 20 small ones. Been lean in the slab department this year. Did get one approaching 15" this year recently but until I caught that one big crappie for the year was a 13". I want them big enough to be worthy of a picture before releasing them. Not many crappie pics on my phone this year, much better with the bass this year.
