Which and why ?

[skunked again]

Fish when it's 45°, and a 5-8mph breeze?
- OR -
Fish when it's 55°, and 15-20mph breeze, with gusts to 30mph?
Sunny both days.

[FurFlyin]

Depends on where and also depends on if the colder day is one day after a front and warmer day is 2nd day after.

[skeetbum]

I seldom pass on a day that I have time to fish. So many times I’ve gone when all the info says that nothing is going to happen and I find fish. They gotta eat sometime and while the window when they turn on may not be long, it’s great when you’re there and everyone else is watching TV. How many times have you heard “ya shoulda bin heah yestiddy “.

[Central Minn]

45 with 5-8 mph breeze would be like a day on the beach.

[Blackjeepjk]

I don’t fish tourney just table fare and enjoyment. I typically won’t go out over 15mph. Just not as much fun for me personally or controlling the boat. Even with ulterra. Over 15, I stay home and take care of honey-do’s
Fish will bite either one.


Sent from my iPad using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app

[Mmirg]

Less wind is always better, but you gotta go when you get the chance.

Sent from my SM-N960U using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app

[SKs Crappie Catching Adventures]

I seldom pass on a day that I have time to fish. So many times I’ve gone when all the info says that nothing is going to happen and I find fish. They gotta eat sometime and while the window when they turn on may not be long, it’s great when you’re there and everyone else is watching TV. How many times have you heard “ya shoulda bin heah yestiddy “.

[pescador]

As long as you are safe, a Quote from Richard Gene.

“Go fishin when you can, Cause its Good Fer Ya”!


Sent from my iPhone using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app

[stormcloud]

15 to 20 with gust to 30 is a no go on big water. When I go I want to enjoy myself whether I load the boat or not. I would not enjoy fishing in that. Both temps are ok.

[Hanr3]

Fish when it's 45°, and a 5-8mph breeze?
- OR -
Fish when it's 55°, and 15-20mph breeze, with gusts to 30mph?
Sunny both days.

I'd fish them both given the chance.
Windier days I'd try to get out of the wind. But you still have to fish where the fish are.