I’ve had similar issues only reverse. There’s many days I’ve had friends out fishing with me while I’m using hi vis line and they’re using clear and I’ve outfished them tremendously. They changed lines and started catching fish. Now the only time I choose clear over hi vis is when I’m bluegill fishing shallow water. I’ve proven it to myself and others that those gills just don’t like the hi vis line attached to a bait. I have special reels lined with 3# clear that I change out when I’m going after gills. I always have some rods rigged with clear in my locker too but hi vis is my go to for crappies.
Well then, after reading this entire post ...... I have determined the defintive answer is "Maybe" followed by "It depends." It's clear as Mud now....