I have a similar Lake James/fire extinguisher story:
Back in 2001 when the Kenner was new, I had talked my Pastor into going fishing with me on Lake James in early April for White Bass at the Linville flats. Early that morning we had caught about a dozen when the warden showed up to chat and check us out. Since everything was almost new (6 months old +-?), I had no worries and made small talk/jokes with both of them as he went through all the regulars. One of the last things he asks for was the extinguisher and I opened one of the compartments, take it out, and hand it to him. I see a frown come over his face as he says this isn't any good..... Of course my response was why not? He turns the gauge towards me and shows me it's on "0". Then a frown came to MY face.... I explained it came with the boat as original equipment and if I'd known it was bad I'd have already replaced it (it's kinda bad giving excuses in front of your Pastor, but there I was). He gave me a short lecture on doing a safety inspection each time you launch since you never know when you'll need the safety gear and wrote me a warning citation.
My takeaway from the experience is: Never take your Pastor fishing. It brings out the Devil!!!
Chris