Originally Posted by
(/\)ishingFishing
Tubes...
I've fished for panfish and bass in the past, but am changing to include crappie more often. Check out the post under "Introduction and report from Auburn Dam." It's a hike from Carlisle, but worth it under the right conditions if you go prepared and spend an entire day there.
I also enjoyed fishing at Project 70 / Codorus State Park, west of York. You can shoot up 11/15 to route 30 pretty quickly that way. It's a huge, unlimited, lake- so there could be some sailboats and the like...but there's a great range of depths, cover, shoreline, and bottom structure there. You'd probably have a good day there, prepared to fish for anything conditions make easy.
There are a few electric-only lakes that are good, including Lake Marquette and Memorial Lake. (Grantville near Indiantown Gap.) I *think,* despite what the Fish Commission site states, that Lake Marquette accepts only rental boats. Either have good shore fishing at times.
Speedwell Forge Lake in Lititz, PA has a nice set of ramps, is large, and has extremely varied habitat and species. I've done very well shore fishing here, and even better under electric on the boat.
I hear Pinchot State Park is good, though it's been years since I was there. I mention it because of your location.
I also want to try Blue Marsh, (Reading,) Wallenpaupak (sp? ...way up north,) and Raystown just for kicks. Let me know if you succeed somewhere else!
Good luck!
-Shawn