The good thing about crappie fishing is there is a time and place for all the different baits. I use my hand tied Jigs most of them time, but on occasion it's hard to beat a blue and with tube, but the same is true for a blue and with jig.
Summer hits and I fall to minnows and jigs in combination and the bigger fish come on the jig.
Your and mine as well as others that tie jigs make a product that will out last minnows and and soft plastic by a mile and that is the confusion with some that have not tried a hand tied jig. They may not realize how many fish they can catch on the same jig without changing tubes or what ever soft plastic. So while our jigs may cost more per jig than tube jigs they also will out live a tube by far and have some actions that soft plastic just can do.
So there is a time and place for all of it IMHO.
Skip