Does your pump pick up water from the livewell or from outside the boat? If it from outside, that line may be obstructed or a switch or lever may not be allowing a valve to open.
If the pump is just recirculating water in the live well it should not need priming. The impleller on the aerator could be broken from the shaft. The motor will turn, no water will pump. Make sure the impeller is turning. There is a small chance the pump is wired backwards and the impeller is turning backwards.