Likes: 
HaHa: 
Reply With QuoteThere is one small pond nearby that produces similar results. I have taken bigger crappie from shore, but only rarely. Plenty of forage in the water too. Maybe it's due to overpopulation?
Minnow
Overpopulation or just a poor forage base?
The lake that I fish at, I usually only catch fish around 7 inches. I did finally catch a couple around 10 inches. I fish from the bank. Are these crappies overpopulated to the point where they don’t get very big or is there not a good enough source of bait or is it a combination of both. Thank you for your input.
Crappie.com Legend
There is one small pond nearby that produces similar results. I have taken bigger crappie from shore, but only rarely. Plenty of forage in the water too. Maybe it's due to overpopulation?
"A voyage in search of knowledge need never abandon the spirit of adventure."PAWildOutdoors thanked you for this post
Crappie Wall Hanger
PAWildOutdoors
Welcome to the challenges of fishing
You've touched on a topic that can give you an array of different reasons here
I would first contact the DNR or google on any information on the lakes potential (if studied)
From there it's a matter of the right combination for Bank fishing (bait, line, scents, etc.)
The O'l saying where there's small ones there's got to be big ones
Good Luck on your success
billygee :rolleyes:
Guppy
PAWildOutdoors,
More than likely the fish are stunted due to over population and poor forage like many small reservoirs in Pa. What part of the state are you from?
Crappie Wall Hanger
Reminds me of cattle watering ponds that were stocked with bream in Alabama. Thousands of bream... all about 2 inches long.
Tom
Minnow
North central PA, I fish potter and tioga counties mainlyOriginally Posted by paicenut
Crappie.com Legend
Read about crappie ...average size is 9 inches....you might have to many or it might be something else ...hard to say ...are they big headed ?
Super Moderator - 2013 Man Of The Year
* Crappie.com Supporter
If you catch them 7" fish in the Spring spawning period & they have eggs ... they're likely stunted from overpopulation. It generally takes about 3yrs for a Crappie to be mature enough to spawn, and they would likely be around the 9" range at that age.
You 'may' also be catching the "bank runners" ... and the larger fish are out in more open/deeper water.
If your DNR or Wildlife Dept. puts out a "fishing forecast" for lakes in your state ... check it to see whether or not those lakes are rated at least "Good" & the general length size available. Anything less than a "good" rating or a length rating below 9" average, and I'd be looking for a different lake to fish.
Crappie Wall Hanger II
Could be stunted, or there could have just been a fantastic spawn 2 years ago, and those fish are what you're catching.
Crappie.com 1K Star General
We have a small 60 acre lake close to me that about 10 years ago was overpopulated with those small 7 inchish fish,you could catch hundreds and they were all the same small size.They actually started to encourage people to take some out when they caught them and even had a Crappie tournament where you caught a 50 fish limit and lowest weight would win.It seems to have helped because the average size has gone up to close to 9 inches and you can sometimes pull a few 10 and 11 inch fish out,still not great but it seems to be on the right path.
